Woman injured in car crash battles ACC for detox treatment in order to have surgery

"It's hard because I live on my own and I don't really have many friends around me."
"It's hard because I live on my own and I don't really have many friends around me." Photo credit: RNZ

By Jimmy Ellingham for RNZ

A woman badly injured in a car crash is battling ACC to cover detox treatment after being told she can't have surgery until she comes off her medication.

Helen Watson feels a prisoner in her own home and a slave to her daily routine that involves sorting through the 23 pills she has to take for pain, to help her sleep and stabilise her mood.

All have been prescribed since the crash, nearly two years ago.

"Hence why I've got to go to detox, to slowly wean off these pills, especially the lorazepam and diazepam, because I could end up having seizures and vomiting because I've been on them a long time," she said.

"My doctor said my body's dependent."

The Feilding 41-year-old said before the crash on November 15, 2020 - where she T-boned another car she said didn't have its lights on at an intersection early in the morning - she played sport, worked and lived a normal life.

That's changed.

"I sleep in until maybe about midday. I wake up and take my pills in the morning then I just go back to bed.

"I maybe knit, watch TV, just fall asleep. Sometimes I walk to the dairy, but that's slow. I'm always tired."

When she can she paints too, but the pills' side effects leave her unable to do much.

She has help looking after her home and section, isn't allowed to drive, and often doesn't feel like eating. Since her crash she's lost about 10 kilograms and now weighs under 60kg.

The drugs are also affecting her oral health - her mouth is always dry and she needs regular appointments at a dental hygienist.

Her father died about seven years ago, but Watson often travels to spend time with friends, who make sure she's eating.

One of the injuries she suffered in the crash is a damaged spinal disc, when an airbag exploded under her chin.

Initially ACC didn't cover the claim, arguing she had existing conditions or injuries, but this was overturned by a review in February.

"Although surgery funding is not an issue directly before me in this review, I note that now that Ms Watson has cover for her cervical disc prolapse, she is entitled to funding for the surgery requested by [Rodney] Gordon, to treat that covered injury," reviewer Ngaire Coddington said.

However, in the 15 months between her crash and Coddington's decision, Watson's medications were increasing.

Gordon, her specialist, who has since retired, told her no one would operate until the amount of medication she's taking was considerably reduced.

Woman injured in car crash battles ACC for detox treatment in order to have surgery
Photo credit: RNZ

That requires weeks at a live-in facility where the medication reduction can be managed - Watson has found a suitable one in Auckland - although ACC isn't yet willing to pay for it.

Watson's advocate Kym Koloni can't understand the decision.

"They have to accept liability for the impact of that accident from the date of that accident.

"On the date of that accident she was not on medication," Koloni said.

"They are trying to find a reason to find a reason to deny her."

Kym Koloni says it was particularly objectionable that ACC raised a sensitive claim from two decades ago, when it's not relevant.

In a statement, ACC's acting deputy chief executive for service delivery Phil Riley said the sensitive claim had no relevance to its assessment of Watson's detox request, but Koloni said the corporation raised it in correspondence about the claim.

Riley said Watson was being asked to complete psychological and psychiatric assessments to see whether detox was the most appropriate treatment.

"We understand Ms Watson has a complex dependency on prescribed medications, which may have been impacted by the effects of her injuries sustained in the car accident."

When RNZ asked for clarification, given Watson wasn't taking medication at the time of her crash, Riley said there was no intent to imply she had a prior drug dependency.

Woman injured in car crash battles ACC for detox treatment in order to have surgery
Photo credit: RNZ

"The most important consideration for funding a residential detox programme is that it is the most appropriate treatment based on the client's holistic needs."

He said the psychiatrist and psychologist were "best qualified to recommend a safe and lasting medication reduction plan for Ms Watson".

Koloni is seeking an urgent review of ACC's decision, seeking immediate approval for funding Watson's detox.

Meanwhile, Watson continues to struggle as she waits for surgery and lives a drugged-up existence.

"It's hard because I live on my own and I don't really have many friends around me. They're all out of town," she said.

"I'm hanging in there, but it's hard."

Watson said she was grateful for Koloni's support and that of City Doctors in Palmerston North, which helps her with her medication.

Even if detox were approved tomorrow she still faces a wait for a spot at the Auckland clinic. The earliest one available is next year.